Uncyclopedia:Pee Review/Todd Palin

Main

Current

Reviewed

Archive

Guidelines

FAQ

Committee

RotM

Todd Palin

I've taken this down the primrose path, and now leave it here to ferment and age. The page started out as a wikipedia spork, and will replace the wikipedia page as the authoritive article on the subject, Todd. Poor Todd. Aleister 14:11 8 1 '11

Humour:	6	The humor is pretty consistent, I like the depiction of Todd as a full-grown hillbilly with the mind of a child. Maybe add some quotes (If he is capable of speaking, that is). I didn't find anything that was really stand-out funny, but it wasn't bad.
Concept:	7	This was a good idea for an article; I'm a little surprised that it hadn't been expanded upon before. This is the kind of thing I like to see, because Todd Palin is something that I might realistically have come to this site and searched for, and few things suck more than searching for something you want to see and not finding a completed article on it.
Prose and formatting:	9	I didn't find anything wrong with the prose in my skim of the article. Really good editing for the amount of content you included, actually.
Images:	7	Good use of images, though I had to take off a few points for the disturbing image of Sarah Palin. I liked the overly hillbilly images.
Miscellaneous:	8	I like this article because it's politically relevant and it's funny without being too far removed from reality.
Final Score:	37	Regardless of how good it is, this article is essential to the site. It seems like you spent a good amount of time on it, and it doesn't feel rushed. There's still room for expansion, which is a good thing, because this is the kind of topic where other people probably have little bits that they want to say about it, and now a good strong base has been established.
Reviewer:	User:Romy